Sponsored
Manhattan apartment dispute involving NYPD and tenant Matthew Charles Albertell

Tenant Says NYPD Aided Removal of His Belongings

An opinion piece by Deroy Murdock describes a Manhattan housing dispute that has turned into a bizarre collision between private property, police procedure, and alleged criminal charges. Murdock says his friend and longtime associate, Matthew Charles Albertell, has faced NYPD scrutiny over alleged extortion and grand larceny even as Albertell says he was the person whose belongings were taken. Since summer 2025, Murdock says the situation has also included apparent NYPD misconduct, threats of criminal charges, and alleged abuse of Albertell’s parents. That is quite a legal mess, with Kafka and George Orwell apparently sharing a desk.

Murdock says he has known Albertell since 2018 and worked with him on political and commercial projects. He describes Albertell as patriotic and professionally capable. According to the account, the trouble began after Albertell moved into 75 West End Avenue in Manhattan in early August 2025. He rented a room in Apartment P18D after an oral agreement with Shahzad Pirvani, who was supposed to be his only roommate. Within weeks, Albertell objected when another roommate was brought in, a move he says violated the apartment lease.

The dispute escalated in December. Murdock says Shahzad and his brother, Jahanzeb Pirvani, entered Albertell’s bedroom and took his security cameras. He says he reviewed videos showing the brothers walking through the room until the cameras were disconnected. The footage, as described, turned a bad roommate dispute into something resembling a low-budget surveillance thriller, except the person seeking help allegedly ended up treated like the trespasser. The Pirvanis then allegedly tried to push Albertell out, while he maintained that he had a legal right to remain in the room he had rented.

On December 11, two unidentified NYPD officers reportedly came to Albertell’s door. An audio recording described by Murdock includes one 20th Precinct officer saying, “Technically, the landlords, or owner of the property cannot remove you,” while explaining that a tenant who had been there more than 30 days would need to be taken through Landlord/Tenant Court. A judge would issue the order, and the Sheriff’s Department would handle the eviction. That sounds like a straightforward explanation of due process, not an invitation for officers to improvise a new rule on the spot.

Yet Murdock says the next step went in the opposite direction. On December 15, about half a dozen NYPD officers, including Michael I. McGoldrick, Badge No. 13374, allegedly entered the residence without Albertell’s consent. The operation also involved movers and the Pirvani brothers. According to the account, officers ignored Albertell’s objections while the Pirvanis removed clothing, jewelry, accessories, and other personal property from his room. Albertell told Murdock, “December 15 was the day the Pirvani brothers came with movers, and the apartment was stripped. My room was left with only the mattress on the floor.”

A legal pleading dated October 20, 2026, is cited as further support for the account. Jahanzeb Pirvani stated under penalty of perjury, “On December 15 [2025], after several hours and only with the NYPD officers present, we entered and removed certain of our personal belongings under their supervision.” Murdock argues that those “personal belongings” apparently included Albertell’s property. The piece also points to New York City Administrative Code § 26-521 and New York Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law § 768, saying a lawful occupant of 30 days or more, or a leaseholder, cannot be removed without a formal court-ordered eviction warrant or government vacate order.

If that account is accurate, the alleged conduct raises an obvious question: why explain the rules of due process on December 11, then appear to disregard them four days later? Police are supposed to enforce the law, not help one side settle a roommate dispute by emptying the other side’s bedroom. A mattress left on the floor is not a court order, no matter how many uniforms are standing nearby.

Albertell’s case, as presented by Murdock, combines disputed housing rights, alleged property theft, and criminal accusations that Murdock characterizes as unsupported. New Yorkers should not need a camera, a legal pleading, and a forensic accounting of their own missing belongings just to be heard. The Gateway Pundit opinion asks whether the people tasked with protecting property rights instead helped erase them.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v%3Dw5AlpZ4JTVM&source=gmail&ust=1795186059980000&usg=AOvVaw11KRElVypwg4i0sK2P8dhU

Source: The Gateway Pundit

More Reading

Post navigation

Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Brooklyn Building Partially Collapses, Firefighters Sift Through Rubble by Hand